man tying his sneakers before a workout

How To Choose The Right Athletic Shoes For Any Workout

Tell your friends!

This post may contain affiliate links. If you click through a link and make a purchase, I may receive a commission at no additional cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Read the full disclosure here.

Let’s talk shoes.

When was the last time you went shopping for new workout shoes?

Did you know what to buy or did it come down to which sneakers were the most attractive? Or in your size? Or on sale?

It can be tempting to just use the same gym shoes for every workout, but this article will fill you in on why that’s a bad idea. Learn how to choose the right gym shoes for any workout to keep your feet (and the rest of you) happy and injury-free!

Disclaimer: This content is for educational purposes and is not medical advice. Read the full disclaimer.

WHY DOES PROPER FOOTWEAR MATTER FOR YOUR WORKOUT?

A proper shoe is one of the most essential components of your fitness routine.

Sneakers are built with different features suited for different workouts. In fact, wearing the wrong shoe can set you up for injuries like plantar fasciitis, shin splints, meniscus tears, or even a total wipe-out!

I used to wear running sneakers for everything. Luckily, I never got an injury. They were my go-to shoes and felt fine.

When I started buying the right gym shoes for each type of workout, I noticed a huge difference! Now, if I’m accidentally wearing running sneakers, it feels completely “off” for me.

Today we’re breaking down some popular categories so you can feel way more confident the next time you buy workout shoes.

Related Read: 11 Signs You’re Wearing the Wrong Shoes for Your Workout

RUNNING

Whether you’re running outside or on a treadmill, invest in a good pair of running shoes.

A running shoe provides cushioning and support as you roll through your foot during the gait cycle. They also come in different levels of support to complement your natural level of pronation.

Textured bottoms help give you a good grip on the surface to keep you from sliding around.

For a lightweight, eco-friendly running shoe option, check out the Allbirds Tree Dasher.

A minimalist shoe (or barefoot shoe) allows you to “feel the ground,” but has less shock absorption and may not be the best choice for everyone.

Running shoes are excellent for running, but shouldn’t be mistaken as a one-stop shop for all your fitness shoe needs.

WALKING

Many people use running shoes for walking as well, and find that a running shoe functions better than a traditional walking shoe.

In general, walking shoes tend to be clunky and not very attractive.

This article by Very Well Fit goes in-depth on the differences between running and walking shoes and is an informative read if you’re in the market for this type of shoe.

SNEAKERS FOR CARDIO WORKOUTS

Running sneakers have a very textured, grippy bottom to provide traction. This is fabulous for running, but cardio classes that involve pivoting and twisting don’t play well with grippy bottoms. 

As a physical therapist, I’m always down for setting yourself up for injury-free success. Knowing what not to do is just as important. I’ve seen meniscus tears and other knee injuries as a result of wearing running shoes to dance fitness classes. 

Don’t be the next knee injury!

CROSS TRAINING SHOES

Cross trainers are a gym shoe that works well for mixed cardio classes, kickboxing, HIIT, aerobics, and circuit training classes.

Look for a cross-training shoe with a smoother bottom to allow for pivoting as well as lateral stability for side-to-side movements. There is also some shock absorption during plyometric or high-level cardio exercises.

Read the details when searching for cross-trainers, some sneakers claiming to be cross trainers lack lateral stability. The training shoe category is becoming a loose term, make sure you get the features you’re looking for. 

Here are some popular cross training styles (made for both men and women) with great reviews:

Of these three, I like the Nike Metcon best, because it fits my foot the best. I have a few pairs of the No Bull trainers. They’re very good quality and I like them for some cross-training activities, but they are slightly wider on my foot. It’s worth noting that I do size up 1/2 size in both of these brands.

a man in a gym doing box jumps and wearing cross training shoes. a decorative image in an article about how to choose the right athletic shoes for any workout.
image source: depositphotos.com

STRENGTH TRAINING

For weight training, a stable shoe with less cushioning is a good choice. This allows for better stability and helps balance load.

A cross-training shoe is a good option, plus you can wear them for other workouts.

For serious weight lifting, a specific weight lifting shoe is an option. This type of shoe has a raised heel to help with form and a strap over the mid-foot to help keep you grounded.

This article by Crossfit Survival goes deep into the differences between cross-training and weight lifting shoes.

The bottom line, you shouldn’t be doing your strength training in cushiony running shoes!

DANCE FITNESS SHOES

If you’re a Zumba or dance fitness devotee, check out dance sneakers!

They have more flexibility and a smooth bottom to allow you to get your samba on without sticking to the floor. And look like a pro.

COURT SNEAKERS

Sports like tennis, volleyball, basketball, or any other court-based sport all have their own category to provide stability, cushioning and support. 

Shop for a sport-specific shoe to up your game.

CYCLE CLASS SHOES

Do you love to spin? Invest in a pair of cycling shoes. 

Cycle shoes are game-changers. They have specialized clips to keep your feet in place and a hard sole to support your foot during standing positions.

While you can ride the bike with your sneakers strapped into the cage, as you stand your shoes will bend and place additional stress on the mid-foot.

I just replaced my cycle shoes after 5 years of consistent use.  You will get your money’s worth out of a good pair.

If you’re using regular sneakers during spin class, opt for shoes with a more supportive sole.

woman in an indoor cycle class wearing cycle shoes
image source: Javier Sanchez Mingorance / bigstockphoto.com

YOGA, PILATES, & BARRE FITNESS CLASSES

Yoga, Pilates, and Barre classes don’t require shoes. Grip socks are an excellent option to provide more traction. 

For Pilates and barre classes, flexible soled ballet shoes can give a bit more support if you have additional foot issues that cause discomfort while barefoot.

The Bloch Pilates Studio Shoe is a unique soft shoe option with a rubber heel, which may offer some support if you have heel pain or plantar fasciitis.

Some Barre and Pilates studios may have policies requiring socks, be just be aware.

WHAT SHOES NOT TO WEAR FOR WORKOUTS

Avoid wearing casual sneakers or street shoes during exercise. 

By casual sneakers, I mean non-athletic sneakers that were made for fashion, not function.

To be clear….I’m not hating on casual shoes, but any type of slip-on sneaker without a back or laces has no place in your workout.

Casual shoes are not designed to support and cushion your foot and ankle for exercise activities. 

GENERAL FIT CONSIDERATIONS FOR ATHLETIC SHOES

Try sneakers on with athletic socks. Look for sneakers that have plenty of room for your toes to wiggle and a snug fit cradling the heel and support thru the mid-foot.

You should never feel like there is excessive rubbing in any one area or like the foot is sliding or twisting inside the shoe. Consider going up a half size if you feel contact with the front of the shoe before exercising. 

The goal is to be comfortable and well supported during activity. You can always add custom or over the counter inserts for additional padding or support. There is no shortage of athletic shoe brands, find the one that works for you. 

If your exercise routine has variety, your sneakers should have the range to match. 

Multiple options will extend the life of your footwear, meaning you will need to replace less often. Consider it an investment in your health. 

HOW TO TELL WHEN ATHLETIC SHOES NEED TO BE REPLACED

The most visible signs of wear and tear are wearing the tread off the bottom of the shoe. If any part of the tread appears to be peeling off, this could be a tripping hazard.

Not so apparent signs include an increase in achy feet after a workout. Keep an eye out for pain in other places such as shins, calves, or knees, as this can also signal it’s time to get new shoes. 

Related Read: 11 Signs You’re Not Wearing the Best Shoes for Your Feet

WRAPPING UP

By now you should be well versed in how to choose the perfect shoe for any workout!

Wearing the wrong shoes for fitness activities can cause foot, ankle, knee, hip, or even low back issues. Issues can arise over time and work their way up the kinetic chain.

Selecting the right workout shoe for each activity will help you avoid fitness injuries. Use these tips to build a gym shoe collection that works for you!

Featured image credit: Nick Aldi / bigstockphoto.com

Tell your friends!

Scroll to Top Skip to content